There was nothing wrong with gwf as it was. It was threads like this that gave them the idea to make the change on the 7/18 patch. Which is the worst idea ever and will make the game less competitive or fun.

Dont like the situation in your current guild or realm
change
its that simple. On server 1 there's little to no competition in any realm except forest. I was in dark and saw this, tried to make dark get more competitive. No one was interested at the time, so i moved to forest realm. I have GWF every night, we win some we lose some. Its fun.

Some people want the complete opposite. They want to sit in a dominant guild and not have real competition. That is fine. You can do that too. if you wante dthings to be more competitive you should never have started a thread like this which lead to the dumb idea of making GWF server wide on servers 11 and up. Which will basically make 1 guild/realm dominant and the rest bored and if they want to be competitive again they have to go to another server.

As I mentioned Server 1 only has forest realm with guilds actually competiting against each other every night for cities. We have one level 4 guild 2 level 3s that are almost level 4 and another level 3 guild. But other realms are starting to get this way too. So it was working just fine as is. There is no need to change it. It was never broke, it was awesome.; Now the new way is horrible and insures I never start a new server, becuase I prefer competition, not just sitting in either the one guild that owns everything or not.