Quote Originally Posted by iamvillainx_4175688 View Post
not correct. you lose shield if you attack a PLAYER. baal/cerb are npc. same as in wilds when you attack an npc with shield on.

The issue i think is that they are revenging you chuck. When you are revenged, you do not get a shield even if you lose.
But the fun part is - when someone have shield - he cant be revenged! Revenger will have an error message "Your target have a shield". You see?