Guild Contributions

[Greggor]

Not sure if anyone at Tynon will see this nut I would like to suggest that the way players can contribute to their guild be altered slightly.

Right now only someone that has actually bought gems can do the 15 gems contribution and only a VIP3 or higher can do the 100 gem contribution. Although I understand the basic principle here with the addition of Guild Chests I think there needs to be a more equitable way of allowing contribution. Right now the lowest contribution of 10,000 coins gets you 50 contrib points. I think this is the part that should be changed. I think it could work like this:

10,000 = 50 contrib

50,000 = 100 contrib

100,000 = 150 contrib

This would require moving the 15 gem investment to say 400 - 500 contrib to keep everything in line but it would allow no-paying players a better opportunity to contribute to their guilds growth.

Anyway I think you should re-look at guild contributions to continue to balance the game a bit more.

Best,

Greggor

[Shock]

Not sure if anyone at Tynon will see this nut I would like to suggest that the way players can contribute to their guild be altered slightly.

Right now only someone that has actually bought gems can do the 15 gems contribution and only a VIP3 or higher can do the 100 gem contribution. Although I understand the basic principle here with the addition of Guild Chests I think there needs to be a more equitable way of allowing contribution. Right now the lowest contribution of 10,000 coins gets you 50 contrib points. I think this is the part that should be changed. I think it could work like this:

10,000 = 50 contrib

50,000 = 100 contrib

100,000 = 150 contrib

This would require moving the 15 gem investment to say 400 - 500 contrib to keep everything in line but it would allow no-paying players a better opportunity to contribute to their guilds growth.

Anyway I think you should re-look at guild contributions to continue to balance the game a bit more.

Best,

Greggor

If they would do this, I think it would make more sense

100k = 50 con
500k = 100 con
1M = 150

Those small gold investments would have everyone doing the 100k contributions...

[Bubba87]

It could also be scaled with guild level:
Level 1: 10k, 50k, 100k, 15 gem, 100gem
Level 2: 20k, 100k, 200k, 15 gem, 100 gem
et. al.

[tesoffer]

posted elsewhere but I found this thread so copied it here

I'd like to see players be able to contribute more... of course it would cost more coins/gems... say like this..

you can contribute up to 3 times each day.
each of the gem contributions can only be done 1 time per day so at vip 3 115 gems = 2200 base contribution and then coins 10000 for another 50 total 2250 for day...
note the reputation bonus only given for FIRST bought each day. (so only contribution increases not reputaion)

but what about those that are not vip 3 (or even 1)

well coins can be done up to 3 times per day... (so total of 150 cotribution per day not including assistant bonuses etc)
and cost of 2nd contribution in coins is 50,000
3rd coin contribution is 200,000 coins.
the above is suggested amounts and could be higher... as stated above

this allows even a non vip to get guild benefits and still grow their contribution to buy tech as well but doesn't allow vips to run away either. 2250 base vs 150 is still high...
but then 50 vs 2000 is still going to let them do what they want ANYWAY.

consider that we now can buy/get
guild benefits (100 contrib)
3 guild chests (150 contrib)
per day.
so, unless you are vip, you either ignore doing either each day. (so you can buy tech) or buy a chest each day and pray for + contribution (or something better)