I agree that attacks in the Caribbean should be limited but not with the same rules as the Wilds. This is what I would propose:
- On the Dock (not sailing) for less than 5 seconds, one level lower than the attacker and above. Gives them a better chance for the partner to board.
- On the Dock (not sailing) for than 5 seconds or more, three levels lower then the attacker and above (same as the Wilds).
- Sailing, at least one of the two sailors is three levels lower than the attacker and above (same as the Wilds).