What I think several of these people that do not want server wide GW has not participated in them. Even as a top player there comes a point where you get stuck for weeks at a time. This makes the game very very boring. The addition of server wide guild wars would actually make the game fun again for everyone. Where is the challenge at all in GW's now for server 1-10. There is none. On server 1 right now, you could take any one of our top 7 guys and that one person could beat any single other guild in our realm. Heck our top 5 guys could beat the rest of the entire realm by themselves. This makes for a very boring server once you reach a certain level.

Where as on server 1 there are 5 top guilds total, which would make GW's very interesting again. And if losing the benefits you have already is the driving force, then I would have to go with Dawn's idea of holding one city and increasing the rewards for that city. But then again by doing this you would essentially be doing the same thing as we are doing now.