Thanks Kaisim, your formation was the difference. Beat the Minister after almost 4 weeks of hard trying. Tried every formation, but never thought of isolating Rhize. I went from 11 million power to 15 million power during those 4 weeks and it didn't seem to make a difference, couldn't get over 70% damage. I had Adamanti and Bloodstorm before the patch so am one of the lucky ones. Most of the Guild I am in will not get Blood for weeks, so I don't know how they are going to beat the Minister. Even with the change in formation and reaching level 80 with all the additional rune slots it still seems that I need at least one stun from Shayd to beat him. I think that gving Blood a high level Messiness seemed to help also, he has stood toe to toe with the Minister for 5 or 6 rounds and survived, not often but enough times.

I beat Ingris the same night, but have stopped dead at the mud golem. I find I do not have the will to work hard on him now, I am burnt out from the Minister. I give the golem a couple of shots and then get out of HR.