General Alcibiades vs King Horemheb

[Andy]

I am going to replace Calvin with either General Alcibiades or King Horemheb but I am having trouble deciding on the one to use. The other Heroes that I will use are Blood, Adam, King Theseus,a and Queen Bryn. I Currently use Calvin and the Main as the tanks with Adam as the sub. Whomever I decide on will start with Half Angel II from a transfer.

Any suggestions would be appreciated.

[goffdoffing]

I don't have horemheb but I love alci! please tell me what good is Queen B? I am playing her and she is not stunning and her hitpoints are 5000-6000. I have level 11 intenseness and 10 preciseness on her.

[VillainX]

From what I have seen of Horemb id take General A over him any day. I love my Alcibiades.

[Wildflower]

I love Alci and his damage.

Not yet seen King H do significant enough damage to be considered.
He seems to suffer from the same lack as Pompey, King T and Queen B.

[Andy]

The highest ranked player in our server also uses General A so I will go with him. Thanks. As far as Queen Bryn I was told that you need a very high hit point for her to shine. level 12 rune was suggested.

[Herby]

I love Alci and his damage.

Not yet seen King H do significant enough damage to be considered.
He seems to suffer from the same lack as Pompey, King T and Queen B.

You find Pompey and Bryn weak? lol

Don't use them with your current gear and runes.

They both shine with top-tier equipment.

Pompey alone can damage up to 700k in banish. And he retains morale.

[mattp169]

yes so what pompey does 700k in one hit then he does much less then less the longer the round goes. While lance stays consistent. My gear for him is justice sword rest lb and mine crits for 650-750k and then does 300-350 ever round and if he gets 2 crits in a round which i have had happen, then he out does pompey easily. M lance crits quite often in banish. But Pompey is one way to do massive damage in banish. And he has some use in HR. But for PvP I find him less then stellar. Bryn is a random factor. Can make the difference in PvP sometimes or be a waste of space in PvP. Depending on your talents and gear shes makes a nice 3rd stunner for banish. Ive only seen King T a few times, not totally impressed their either. I dont see it crit as much as my adam - which makes no sense to me. Mabe the ones I have seen need a little more work on runes and gear to get the full effect out of him.

But I do see a pattern when it comes to all these heroes who are maintaining morale. However what I see missing in the heroes is there is no Gold that drains morale. There are 4 gold heroes that retain morale now. yet no gold hero to counter that effect. Flavius might have been the point to balance that, but i feel he should be powered up just a bit more and made a gold to add a little balance

[Yelsha]

Off topic, but does lance out damage blood in banish?

[Herby]

yes so what pompey does 700k in one hit then he does much less then less the longer the round goes. While lance stays consistent. My gear for him is justice sword rest lb and mine crits for 650-750k and then does 300-350 ever round and if he gets 2 crits in a round which i have had happen, then he out does pompey easily. M lance crits quite often in banish. But Pompey is one way to do massive damage in banish. And he has some use in HR. But for PvP I find him less then stellar. Bryn is a random factor. Can make the difference in PvP sometimes or be a waste of space in PvP. Depending on your talents and gear shes makes a nice 3rd stunner for banish. Ive only seen King T a few times, not totally impressed their either. I dont see it crit as much as my adam - which makes no sense to me. Mabe the ones I have seen need a little more work on runes and gear to get the full effect out of him.

But I do see a pattern when it comes to all these heroes who are maintaining morale. However what I see missing in the heroes is there is no Gold that drains morale. There are 4 gold heroes that retain morale now. yet no gold hero to counter that effect. Flavius might have been the point to balance that, but i feel he should be powered up just a bit more and made a gold to add a little balance

You missed one thing in comparing them. Lance requires Herja to be effective in banish. Pompey does not.
If you let Lance do physical attacks on the boss, thousand strikes will kill your team very quickly.
The key here is that lots of people are dependent on Herja now. One has to let go of this mentality to progress in the game.

And did I mention that Pompey is excellent in PvP and in heroics. Turn 1 kills anything the enemy has in front.

[Revan]

Herja certainly does have her uses, but she is far from a one size fits all hero.

As for the general and king, haven't recruited either yet so no idea if they are any good, but both abilities look interesting.