Should Stuns be Part of Banish Events

[Herby]

Well although our comments will be taken into account, I'm already expecting some changes in the near future.

I don't expect any changes to it anytime soon.

There are a lot more problems and issues to address right now, like CWF issues and GW issues.

Taking away something players like and don't have any problems with, is surely not a way to solve problems.

[Joker]

I don't expect any changes to it anytime soon.

There are a lot more problems and issues to address right now, like CWF issues and GW issues.

Taking away something players like and don't have any problems with, is surely not a way to solve problems.

yea i agree with herby this is not a problem in the game or something that players are complaing , also this forum was not started for this reason it was for complain of lag and idk why the moderators have not closed this forum as I remember they closed the one for lvl 11 and 12 runes.

[hjam_8879649]

Who here who commented has not recently been in at least the top 5 recently? At a reasonable guess all of you, including me.

Stuns and refreshing ensure especially with 1.25b Banish a nice little earner which quite frankly is what the opposition to stun removal is all about. It's nothing about giving non-coiners a chance or increasing the gap between those who spend or not, all seemingly noble statements, but honest? Not really. As it currently stands I really doubt there would be much change to top 10, except a distinct drop in resources and possible return to 250m Banish.

If anyone really wanted to make it fairer you guys would stop using stunners or/and boosting which even I would be honest enough to say, I wouldn't. Guess we're all guilty of the human flaws of greed and ambition.

As for the final decision regarding the stuns in Banish? Well although our comments will be taken into account, I'm already expecting some changes in the near future.

To punish the ones who have worked so hard to get their heros to the point that they are able to do well on WBs is just wrong imo, The main problem with WBs is and always has been that if your not in the top 3 on your out of luck on plans better jewels etc, so instead of screwing with ways to hinder us why not give out better items to those that cant be and may never be in the top 3 for what ever reason ( ie non coiners, part time players, etc etc,) I don't know, but to me it appears to be an easy fix....shrug.

But then maybe it has nothing to do with making players happy and everything to do with players progressing too fast as it always seems to be....well you can only mess around with good players for so long before they get tired of it and move on to other games.

[Morgan le Fay]

I don't expect any changes to it anytime soon.

There are a lot more problems and issues to address right now, like CWF issues and GW issues.

Taking away something players like and don't have any problems with, is surely not a way to solve problems.

If Tynon decide to take something away, they'll do it. Whether it was something players liked or not and there's not a jot you or I can do about it. If it's something that's been suggested by Dawnseeker (who's a rep) then there's a very strong possibly Banish events are being looked into.

yea i agree with herby this is not a problem in the game or something that players are complaing , also this forum was not started for this reason it was for complain of lag and idk why the moderators have not closed this forum as I remember they closed the one for lvl 11 and 12 runes.

The users on this forum often complain when threads are closed that Tynon are 'sweeping things under the carpet'. By suggesting I or another mod close this thread you are trying to do the same. As I replied to Herby, if Tynon change it what can we do about it other than change our formations.

Incidentally the level 11 and 12 rune thread is open. I reedited the title this one because someone commented on Banish stuns and Dawnseeker on behalf of Tynon put forward a suggestion to remove stuns. The discussion then changed direction and since it is one which players like to have a comment on and for the most of it have put forward their views well within forum etiquette, I see no reason to close it.

[Riot]

I wouldn't suggest you post your banish formations in public if you're doing good.
There are better banish formations out there. Herja + Lance combos.

Lance does 20-25% more damage than blood.
Using Herja means you don't need to sacrifice your leader in turn 1, he skills each turn and doesn't add morale.
It also means you can use Cianna as a stunner without adding morale.

That's just for starters.

Good point Herby.

But like someone said, the boss will get lose and kill he heros one by one.

I don't mind sharing my formation as it works well and it would be good to see others also use it to balance the dmg across others.

But i have used cienna (not the best stunner - about 1/2 effective as to shayd with lvl 12 preciseness).

I also used Herja but her lack of dmg... is a wash of putting in a hero doing 200k per hit with no morale loss.

de luc's added dmg by using herja and losing a 200k dmg hero with no morale loss is not worth it IMO. Also Calvin does good dmg and eliminates all morale build up from the boss. She when you sub him.. the center hero that dies.. calvin pops up and removes any built in morale.

But my formation may not be the best and I am open to changing things around to experiment further.

I will report back on results.

Herja, De Luc, Pompey, Main, Shayd (vs. Cienna), blood (sub)

[Dawnseeker]

I only bring your feedback to the developers. I may kick around ideas with you guys, but if you don't like them, I don't bring them up to the devs. My job is to represent you guys. A lot of times players want things that are impossible or unreasonable, but sometimes we can come up with things that are right on the money. I'm just trying to guide discussion down realistic avenues, as that is more productive.

[Deucalion]

Who here who commented has not recently been in at least the top 5 recently? At a reasonable guess all of you, including me.

Stuns and refreshing ensure especially with 1.25b Banish a nice little earner which quite frankly is what the opposition to stun removal is all about. It's nothing about giving non-coiners a chance or increasing the gap between those who spend or not, all seemingly noble statements, but honest? Not really. As it currently stands I really doubt there would be much change to top 10, except a distinct drop in resources and possible return to 250m Banish.

If anyone really wanted to make it fairer you guys would stop using stunners or/and boosting which even I would be honest enough to say, I wouldn't. Guess we're all guilty of the human flaws of greed and ambition.

As for the final decision regarding the stuns in Banish? Well although our comments will be taken into account, I'm already expecting some changes in the near future.

I give up. Take it all away. BTW CWF just started out of nowhere without warning, ty.

[Herby]

If Tynon decide to take something away, they'll do it. Whether it was something players liked or not and there's not a jot you or I can do about it. If it's something that's been suggested by Dawnseeker (who's a rep) then there's a very strong possibly Banish events are being looked into.

I disagree. Dawnseeker had a tongue-sticking-out-smile in that.


Also, as a volunteer forum moderator, it would be highly expected of you Morgan, to be unbiased in your views in the posts that you make in this forum.

It doesn't take a genius to find out which way you lean on Morgan. Just need to read some of your posts.

Tynon lag caused a party in the battle

Also, since this thread is WAY OFF-TOPIC, and the thread title was even changed to make it more off-topic.

I suggest this thread be closed.

(the image above is the thread's initial post)

[Deucalion]

You and I Herby, are on the same exact page.

[hjam_8879649]

I give up. Take it all away. BTW CWF just started out of nowhere without warning, ty.

Ya lol , CW is rolling and like 10 mins before WB.....cant change into WB formation lol.....well i could and still win most of the fights i guess...but I dont wanta..