Quote Originally Posted by smokingfox View Post
some things i like here and some things i dont and its more of a NEW event then a change

because u go from pvp to pve which imo ruines the concept

i love to see this ADDED as a new event.. maybe change the rewards to something else then city's.

this looks like fun but how will this work for a guild that only has 3-4 players left? and is lvl 4-5.. cant beat boss coz its to strong?
ok this is a valid point. - but lets examine why my idea even works for them.

And maybe some of this got left out of the original post so if it is sorry.

You have a guild that is level 5 and only has 4 members.
with my idea they now get all the buffs up to level 5. SO now they can get stronger.
They dont have to fight the toughest city every day. They can simply fight the easiest city - the level 1 - which 4-5 players who have been playing for a while and who now have the advantage of the city buffs should be able to take it down because a level 1 city would be set up for 10 or so players who just started the game to be a challenge but able to beat with a little work after a week or so of building up.
And now since city buffs are given out by guild level not by city this encourages players to be in different guilds and not feel tied down to the guild that has the city buffs. This encourages movement and can actually change the make up of realms and servers over time.

Now yes this changes an event that was designed to be PvP to PvE. Because the original concept is only working on a very few select servers. But this idea does not stop a new PvP guild versus guild event to be added, like the king of the hill idea I posted somewhere.

I am not saying that there should be no guild vs guild PvP. I am just saying that the way it is now does not work well, theres going to be too many people complaining about city buffs if you just tweak GWF. SO lets take all the arguments for not changing GWF off the table - THE BUFFS. Make the current GWF that we are all used to seeing different and then leave the door open for a new PvP guild versus guild event.