Heroics

[Herby]

for me atleast it isnt about being ranked or copying formations...on my server me and another guy pretty much take turns to be the 1st and we often use very different forms, but i want to beable to go back and see what form i used on some bosses and also checking the other guys forms as i find them very strange and fun at times. (not saying i dont try others formations when im stuck for a long time, just in general i tweak my own forms)

Yes, what you're doing is quite admirable, trying to learn the intricacies of the game's tactics and startegies.
You're of a rare breed though. Most players just want the replays so they can copy them and beat the boss and move on.