What a JOKE Championship Warfare has turned out to be.

[Morgan le Fay]

Think about it? How many times is this going to happen? If it's happened once it'll happen again and just because you think it's OK this time is advocating it in the future.

As for the comments about not throwing it for someone outside her guild is the the whole darn point. Why should Nixon get the Champ rewards when someone who equally could've fought their way to the final would've lost. Nothing complicated about it your're just making excuses.

[WickeD]

I guess i can explain a few things here , All strong players fall in the same bracket as Yue and they get eliminated before the Finals , Next championship i see a final between Yue and Kruize , i bet this will happen . I know its not fair but well i am just a noob and i will live with it

[WickeD]

Nooberix and Morgan you both need to chill , its over and it will happen again and again so lets not waste all our energies arguing today .

[Nooberix]

Making excuses for who their guild ? You got it all wrong I take great pleasure in knocking their guild members off in CW
So you want him to throw games for others who are not in his guild do you think he is that stupid?

If some other player had defeated Nixon then Nixon would have not gained the benefit but they did not and he did so you see if you want to stop this make sure you are there in the finals against Yue problem solved.
Yes if they had manipulated the games to make sure 2 of their guild members made it to the finals that would be wrong and against the rules. But it so happened that 2 of them made it to the finals and they made the most of it. I see no problem there.

[Nooberix]

I guess i can explain a few things here , All strong players fall in the same bracket as Yue and they get eliminated before the Finals , Next championship i see a final between Yue and Kruize , i bet this will happen . I know its not fair but well i am just a noob and i will live with it

You probably right but then what can you do. Just do what you can and hope luck is in your favour or the tynon gods smile upon you

[Morgan le Fay]

Nooberix and Morgan you both need to chill , its over and it will happen again and again so lets not waste all our energies arguing today .

Cool as a cucumber me. I was just explaining that if you advocate it once, like a snowball the initial problem gets bigger. So for arguments sake eventually it's possible one guild could end up picking the champ every fortnight. Don't think I'm over exaggerating, these things have happened in other games. However, like you I'm relatively small so I have no ambitions, it's the 'it's OK' attitude that has me making the dent in my desk larger.

Then what is the point of Championship Warfare.

[tuckmeng01_8614397]

I think I got a long term solution to this problem. 1st all players once enter into CW will auto strip off all their heroes just his main character, all his/her equipment and runes too. All they have to rely on are their talents. Then there won't be any hanky panky What u think guys?

[Andy]

I don't know maybe it's because I'm older I can see why others are up in alms. Everyone who's saying it was Yue's to give away is half right, it was and no actual rules were obviously broken. However, I'm surprised at the flippant attitude being shown towards those who are upset by this.

Yue is by far the best player on the Asia-Pacific servers and thoroughly deserve that accolade. She gave away the CW to a guild mate, fine. But would she'd done the same if she faced an opponent who wasn't in her guild, I think everyone knows the answer to that, a resounding no. If the boot was on the other foot I bet there would be one or two here who'd complain about that.

Tynon isn't a sport, agreed but it is a game and does require a degree of sportmanship that's why there are rules and TOS. CWF isn't a guild event, it's an individual competition for the best players to come out on top, yes it could be tweaked a bit but nevertheless that's what it is. So if a player is prepared to throw a match it's his/her choice but that player must be prepared to do it for everyone rather than just his/her guildies or friends.

This would all be true if there was no betting involved. Because of the betting every one that bet on the event is affected. They bet based on who they thing is going to win based on the player's strength and savvy. When the player trows the fight all of that goes out the window and the ones that had bet in the event have a real reason to be upset because they lost tokens that they should have rightfully been theirs.

[Jupitor]

This would all be true if there was no betting involved. Because of the betting every one that bet on the event is affected. They bet based on who they thing is going to win based on the player's strength and savvy. When the player trows the fight all of that goes out the window and the ones that had bet in the event have a real reason to be upset because they lost tokens that they should have rightfully been theirs.

I could see people being mad about the champ tokens...but honestly they still get some when they lose a bet and it's not like they are losing anything when they lose. Unless they put gems on it....but then that's their fault because it's not worth it to bet gems in CW.

In my opinion, I could care less who threw what in Championship Warfare. There's nothing in the battle rules or the ToS that says it's not allowed. All I really see from what I've read about the situation, Yue was just trying to help out a smaller guild mate. I honestly don't see anything wrong with that, I think it's a decent change to see the top player who's won how many of the CWs? helping out the smaller players.

But that's just me..

[g346007_1906957]

Just curious... what is the definition of an exploit? Because this 'doesn't break any rules', but takes advantage of the rules and obviously isn't the intended way of playing. Looking at the sailing exploit (I'll bring this up because it was resolved), there was no rule that you had to claim rewards right after you sailed, but we all know that was an exploit.

Then again, there is also powering down in HP and such... so I just want to know what counts and what doesn't.