Well if they started the fight might as well sink them. Being called a "cheater" for sinking ships in the carribean is not reasonable. I find it pretty pathetic that the person would think that is a reason to report. And you can't really cheat on Tynon, there is being a "bully" on Tynon where you attack on a guild or person. I do not know if you can get banned for "bullying" someone in the game. Hope that answers your question.