Is GW a source of dissatisfaction for you?

[ChickenWing]

Recently, a lot of people have suggested that Guild Warfare be changed.

Here are some of the suggestions:

Some people are unhappy with guilds teaming up to dominate:
http://bbs.tynon.com/showthread.php?...d-Wars-an-idea

Some people are unhappy with ubber guilds dominating a server
http://bbs.tynon.com/showthread.php?...ag-replace-gwf

And many people, notably Herby, suggested that guilds should be able to hold a limited amount of cities.

Guild Warfare seems to be a total failure and a major cause for people quitting a server in all servers except 1-10.

So here's poll. The question is simple: Is GW a source of dissatisfaction for you?

I don't want people to state why in the poll. I just want to survey the level of dissatisfaction with GW. However, feel free to post your reasons by commenting on this thread.

[ChickenWing]

I'm not sure I like the fact that this was moved here. Yes, there is a section for GW, but most people don't read it, which is why I posted under General Discussion.

EDIT: Nevermind, people can still see it in general discussion.

[Morgan le Fay]

I'm not sure I like the fact that this was moved here. Yes, there is a section for GW, but most people don't read it, which is why I posted under General Discussion.

EDIT: Nevermind, people can still see it in general discussion.

It's simple really. Too many threads are being created in General Discussion and there is somewhat of a jam. So if threads can be moved to less cluttered forums people are more likely to find them. Especially with the Merge thread being so active.

[Jewels]

I click 'new posts'
pretty much lets me see whats active and hot at the moment - the scrolling through threads esp gen discussion is too time consuming

[davidschlebusch_6020359]

GW for me imo is fine as it is ... we get the rewards for the cities we have fought for, now youre asking for us to throw away our efforts?
I dont think so

[ChickenWing]

GW for me imo is fine as it is ... we get the rewards for the cities we have fought for, now youre asking for us to throw away our efforts?
I dont think so

I'm in the dominant guild on my server, and I find it quite boring. Yes, we put a lot of effort into winning, and I don't like the result quite frankly. From my point of view, it's a matter of keeping the competition alive.

[Jewels]

The buffs are great (but when 1 guild has them people leave)
YES the rewards every night fighting are worth signing on for,
But... Enter at 7pm click B wait, snooze make a samwich click A.... done. If nothing else make it more interesting.

[Morgan le Fay]

I click 'new posts'
pretty much lets me see whats active and hot at the moment - the scrolling through threads esp gen discussion is too time consuming

So do I, much easier. However, when it comes to looking or searching for threads that haven't been posted in since your last visit this is where the problems start, since even threads on GD created that day end on up on the second page .

Back on topic. I won't be voting for either because either you keep it as a PvP style event and one person or guild will dominate or you change it to a PvE and there will be some who will comment on the lack of PvP.

Can't win really.

[Jewels]

Also wanted to add - looks like we have had 2 straight weeks of toons being in the place they were put in, in battle planning so Kudo's tynon for the fix.
Altho now its even more boring without the 'tynon' factor lol

[mattp169]

So do I, much easier. However, when it comes to looking or searching for threads that haven't been posted in since your last visit this is where the problems start, since even threads on GD created that day end on up on the second page .

Back on topic. I won't be voting for either because either you keep it as a PvP style event and one person or guild will dominate or you change it to a PvE and there will be some who will comment on the lack of PvP.

Can't win really.

Yes youcan
its simple
assign the buffs to guild level.
Keep gwf as is except your not fighting over a city/buff your fighting for rewards only cred/coin/exp/rep/contib

Both guilds get a participation reward equal; to what er get already - winning guild gets a small bonus

Thats the first stop gap measure to fixing the entire situation. Then the devs can work on making the pvp gwf thing interesting - after some new content maybe