View Poll Results: Is Guild Warfare a source of dissatisfaction for you?

Voters
39. You may not vote on this poll
  • Yes, I am dissatisfied with GW.

    32 82.05%
  • No, GW is fine as it is.

    7 17.95%
Results 1 to 10 of 32

Thread: Is GW a source of dissatisfaction for you?

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Quote Originally Posted by Morgan le Fay View Post
    Won't matter Matt, people play to win regardless. They will still pick the 'winning' side.

    However got to give you kudos on a well thought out idea.
    ahh but you see there is no real wining side

    in my idea lets say teh participation rewards are 4m coins 2m cred
    teh winning guild gets an additional 1m coin 500k creds.

    thats not a lot to squawk over.

    But now you have all those smaller guilds who refuse to merge in to the big guild who suddenly have the buffs, and can build. Starting to make them little guilds tougher and tougher to beat in gwf. Then when you got 4 of them all coming after you and you have to split your forces.

    Thats the beauty of this very simple idea. every one becomes a winner. until such time they come up with something actually interesting to do for guild pvp. Everyone get to build more. If your tired of the people in your guild and want a change you can now do so without punishment of losing those city buffs. How many people you think are sitting in guilds only because of the buffs, but who like talking to the people in other guilds much better. Theres lots of different mind sets out there. But i think less are going to flock to an uber guild over a few creds/coins every day - where as going to them for these massive buffs is a no brainer and people will do that all day long.

    I personally think everything should be changed to fix the problem of healthy competition in pvp and to make this game more sustainable, Ive outlined many ideas in the forums.some of them seem outlandish. But the underlying problem with teh game structure is the realms guilds and gwf. uCool recognized this early on and changed gwf on 11+. But that made the situation worse instead of better. its high time we throw out this outdated notion of guilds and realms and this boring idea of gwf pvp. revamp the whole thing - make things more competitive on all servers. Cater to the people who have been playing this game forever. Dont take things away give us new things. Give everyone the city buffs. Give everyone something new to do.

  2. #2
    Quote Originally Posted by mattp169 View Post

    Then when you got 4 of them all coming after you and you have to split your forces.
    Matt, I actually like your plan, however you're wrong with this comment. You propose no reward for holding more cities, the reward is tied to guild level, and then additional for winning your battle. So why would anyone split their forces?

  3. #3
    Quote Originally Posted by roy.ant_8586481 View Post
    Matt, I actually like your plan, however you're wrong with this comment. You propose no reward for holding more cities, the reward is tied to guild level, and then additional for winning your battle. So why would anyone split their forces?
    To deny the opposition bonus rewards for winning a battle. If you win all 4 battles, then your guild is the only guild getting the bonus.

    Quote Originally Posted by mattp169 View Post
    Yes youcan
    its simple
    assign the buffs to guild level.
    Keep gwf as is except your not fighting over a city/buff your fighting for rewards only cred/coin/exp/rep/contib

    Both guilds get a participation reward equal; to what er get already - winning guild gets a small bonus

    Thats the first stop gap measure to fixing the entire situation. Then the devs can work on making the pvp gwf thing interesting - after some new content maybe
    Give the winning team an extra sail . I'd prefer sailing over additional rewards for winning...I just like the sea.
    -- Neriya, Beauty of Aphrodite, Server 78.

  4. #4
    Quote Originally Posted by Pirate_1360826 View Post
    To deny the opposition bonus rewards for winning a battle. If you win all 4 battles, then your guild is the only guild getting the bonus.



    Give the winning team an extra sail . I'd prefer sailing over additional rewards for winning...I just like the sea.

    See i think you get it as well. Keep the reward for the winning guild small. It must be significant enough to make it worth doing, but not so big (like the city buffs) to give the winning guild significant advantage so noone else stands a chance

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •