#1-- How does someone attack with 20 alts? Do they have 20 browsers? (the whole "alt" label is very commonly accused upon newer players and less-active players).

#2-- 15 ppl + 30 alts (45 total) is still no match for a guild with 45 people. (and 45 is being generous, as there are guilds with 60-70 active people). And if your server population is so low that a 15 player guild is normal .... shouldn't you be grateful you still have competition?


If you want to discourage alts and not the active players, then the solution is to disable the OFFLINE players (who collected guild benefits) from being in the GW. (ie: no more automated defenders. Have to show up.)