Page 2 of 6 FirstFirst 1234 ... LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 56

Thread: The great new guild warfare!

  1. #11
    Quote Originally Posted by Dawnseeker View Post
    These all sound like good things. Now one guild can't easily hold every city, and guilds must plan out strategy carefully for defense and offense. To me this sounds a lot better than defense saying "Okay all go B and turn 1 kill A" which was what was happening in 90% of GWs before we decided to overhaul it.
    ^^^^ Exactly this. One turn battles in previous guild wars had no strategy or depth. I like the new guild wars far better than the old system.

  2. #12
    I have to agree, now that the waters have had time to settle, its an actual fight.
    Yeah Yeah, I know I don't look like that, but a girl can dream.

  3. #13
    Apprentice
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Location
    LoR II
    Posts
    16
    Quote Originally Posted by Kitiara_3214881 View Post
    Well you DO lose morale in-between fights, so he would at the very least have to have herja buff him or be hit by melee in order to morale again.

    And to OP...lemme get this straight, you're holding 7 cities and complaining that someone just took one from you? You're whats wrong with this game.
    Yes we are holding 7 cities, and I don't really mind losing one.. But its how we are losing it.. See the point of holding cities when 1 person with 76m power can kill an entire guild with maybe around 500m power twice whitout healing or dieing? Because I don't.

  4. #14
    Justice
    Join Date
    May 2013
    Posts
    1,037
    Quote Originally Posted by Dawnseeker View Post
    These all sound like good things. Now one guild can't easily hold every city, and guilds must plan out strategy carefully for defense and offense. To me this sounds a lot better than defense saying "Okay all go B and turn 1 kill A" which was what was happening in 90% of GWs before we decided to overhaul it.
    Not true. I can't speak to all servers, but this B to A still happens on most. 4 of 5 realms still hold all cities/buffs on our server. And the 1 realm that doesn't is stuck in a rut. No one is growing or keeping pace with the rest of the server due to no or inadequate city buffs. It is not fair, never has been and is not better. Maybe the servers that share 1 GW is better, but ours is most certainly NOT.

  5. #15
    Ironheart Cuddles_1461020's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2013
    Location
    +Scandal+
    Posts
    317
    To the Original Poster: Choose your battles/cities wisely. With a 50% boost (up to 70% at F), even Blayd/Riot can be beaten. And if they have Maria (or at a Fort or base that heals) they won't even be scratched.

    To Mischief: I see your point about the 5-realm GW. Yes having no cities is certainly a noticeable disadvantage, and with each realm having 2-3 cities each, your realm may be screwed.
    On the bright side however, it's exponentially easier to keep up with a 0 city-buff vs 3 city-buffs .... than a 0 city vs 9 city-buffs discrepancy like before.


    Cuddles' Law: The volume of a player's whine is directly proportional to his/her VIP level.

  6. #16
    Justice
    Join Date
    May 2013
    Posts
    1,037
    Quote Originally Posted by Cuddles_1461020 View Post
    To the Original Poster: Choose your battles/cities wisely. With a 50% boost (up to 70% at F), even Blayd/Riot can be beaten. And if they have Maria (or at a Fort or base that heals) they won't even be scratched.

    To Mischief: I see your point about the 5-realm GW. Yes having no cities is certainly a noticeable disadvantage, and with each realm having 2-3 cities each, your realm may be screwed.
    On the bright side however, it's exponentially easier to keep up with a 0 city-buff vs 3 city-buffs .... than a 0 city vs 9 city-buffs discrepancy like before.
    And starve. And fall so far behind. I don't see what is good about that. Soon I will either quit the game, or move to a realm that is rich. Jeezus, I didn't work this hard to be bored to tears. Bottom line. And it's a damn shame. But the reality is that, you can't make reps off 1 rep city = fall behind. You can't get stuff in shrine, when it's nearly empty, you can't get ahead at all.... but hey.. Tynon loves it, so who gives a ***.

    And when this game started I loved it!! I loved GW, I was a proponent of it. I spoke out on it. I moved realms to find the fight!!! Until it was utterly turned upside down. Damn shame.
    Last edited by MisChief; 04-15-2014 at 12:40 AM.

  7. #17
    Judgment Revan's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2013
    Posts
    1,512
    Quote Originally Posted by MisChief View Post
    Not true. I can't speak to all servers, but this B to A still happens on most. 4 of 5 realms still hold all cities/buffs on our server. And the 1 realm that doesn't is stuck in a rut. No one is growing or keeping pace with the rest of the server due to no or inadequate city buffs. It is not fair, never has been and is not better. Maybe the servers that share 1 GW is better, but ours is most certainly NOT.
    Servers 1-10 had too much time for the bulk of the smaller guilds to die out and now none that can compete are left. Also the whole each realm has its own guild warfare cities thing makes it worse, the patch was more of intended for the newer servers where most new players end up. Pretty pointless to use them as a measuring stick as to whether something involving guild warfare is having the intended effect.

  8. #18
    Quote Originally Posted by Revan View Post
    Servers 1-10 had too much time for the bulk of the smaller guilds to die out and now none that can compete are left. Also the whole each realm has its own guild warfare cities thing makes it worse, the patch was more of intended for the newer servers where most new players end up. Pretty pointless to use them as a measuring stick as to whether something involving guild warfare is having the intended effect.
    Not completely true. A few guilds have been able to take cities form the uber guilds on servers 1-10

  9. #19
    Server 111 has one GW for all three realms. One guild has 7 cities and two guilds have one city each. The one holding all the cities has 70 players which is the max they can have. The second best guild has 36 players. We can not compete with the one guild since they have so much more rep, coins, credits and now guild chests. They are going to be level 6 in a couple of days and will have 100% rewards for sailing as well. They are not having trouble with the new system.

  10. #20
    Quote Originally Posted by Kitiara_3214881 View Post
    Well you DO lose morale in-between fights, so he would at the very least have to have herja buff him or be hit by melee in order to morale again.

    And to OP...lemme get this straight, you're holding 7 cities and complaining that someone just took one from you? You're whats wrong with this game.
    Wrong. You DONT lose morale between fights.


    OP:
    His Adam is killing everyone first strike with the 50% attack/defense buff he has from all your guild cities.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •