Quote Originally Posted by mattp169 View Post
Ok so i could see how this could work.
But it seems there is an issue.

I would suggest that teh devs actually look at some of teh older servers and carefully go through the logs and see in the realm rankingas are doing what the should be doing. Becuase if wildflower was #1 in realm before UA and never fought a guildmate she should not be able to drop to 3 in realm. And teh fact she had to drop and beat teh person who was 1 in realm to regain 1 in realm makes it make less sense.

to me it should only work 1 of 2 ways

1. UA rank determines realm rank - which does not seem to be happening - but could coasue #2 or lower in realm to become #1 in realm without ever fight #1 in realm by attacking someone higher in UA then #1.

or

2 realm rank only changes when people in the realm fight each other in UA - which sort of seems how it is designed based on what some have said - but does not explain how wildflower dropped from 1 to 3
Option 2 would be very confusing since there would be people that are lower in the UA (the only arena that they can fight in) that have a higher rank in the RA. Since the people on one realm can be widely scattered in the UA it would be difficult to attack a guildy.

Option 1 presents some issues for HP because some one from one realm can change who ends up in HP for another realm.