With no guild wars, the top coiners don't have a reason for their tenure in a guild to be secure.
The host and VHs will wield too much power, since the guild will have all their buffs with no need to defend them.
Alts will only multiply, moreso than they are now.
Morgan, you didn't think that part through.
The guild buffs need to be earned, defended, and possibly lost. Otherwise, there's no reason to try recruiting/maintaining the strong players to your guild anymore.
I know where you are coming from, since I also played in the earlier servers before.
Guild wars in servers 1-10 is boring and lifeless. Its just your guild vs your alt guilds from your realm. B-A. done.
You really should realize that this is not how guild wars is played in the majority of the other servers.
Server 1 actually has a realm with alot more activity than most of the server wide GW, Please have the facts to hand before you think you know best.
GW should be replaced, but with a more up to date version.
Things are getting Dated, Just waiting on the Devs i suppose.
What I Speak is the Truth... What YOU delete must hurt you