[Suggestion] Replace Guild Wars

[Moonshadeaux_3172622]

Sorry people but as long as the alt guilds and alt players are not banned no idea is going to help the honest players. On my server the alt guilds own citys, overbid, pass their big guns around so no one can take their cities. If you want a better game then get tynon support off of its dead a** and clean this game up. Now they have a way to cheat at baal and cerb. 70 mill players are doing more damage then 170 mill players. 8 players and Big Cerb goes down in 20 minutes 2 70 mill players score in the 40% plus range.

[jkwongfl_7919855]

Sorry people but as long as the alt guilds and alt players are not banned no idea is going to help the honest players. On my server the alt guilds own citys, overbid, pass their big guns around so no one can take their cities. If you want a better game then get tynon support off of its dead a** and clean this game up. Now they have a way to cheat at baal and cerb. 70 mill players are doing more damage then 170 mill players. 8 players and Big Cerb goes down in 20 minutes 2 70 mill players score in the 40% plus range.

Power means nothing, especially so in banish.

[Joker]

Having buffs attached to guild level won't work as that way the host and Vice host can just boot the top players once they have reached a specific level. Currently they wont do that as they wil start losing cities if they do thus keeping everyone in line.

[g346007_1906957]

Having buffs attached to guild level won't work as that way the host and Vice host can just boot the top players once they have reached a specific level. Currently they wont do that as they wil start losing cities if they do thus keeping everyone in line.

Yikes... you seem to play with mean people.

[Morgan le Fay]

Having buffs attached to guild level won't work as that way the host and Vice host can just boot the top players once they have reached a specific level. Currently they wont do that as they wil start losing cities if they do thus keeping everyone in line.

Why would they boot the top players if they can help their team win an alternative event to GWs? Anyway no host worth their salt would do that, whether they help keep cities or not. Having the best in their guild is a coup. Not to mention they are usually the best contributors.

[Herby]

Having buffs attached to guild level won't work as that way the host and Vice host can just boot the top players once they have reached a specific level. Currently they wont do that as they wil start losing cities if they do thus keeping everyone in line.

I agree with what Joker has said.


With no guild wars, the top coiners don't have a reason for their tenure in a guild to be secure.

The host and VHs will wield too much power, since the guild will have all their buffs with no need to defend them.

Alts will only multiply, moreso than they are now.


Morgan, you didn't think that part through.

The guild buffs need to be earned, defended, and possibly lost. Otherwise, there's no reason to try recruiting/maintaining the strong players to your guild anymore.


I know where you are coming from, since I also played in the earlier servers before.

Guild wars in servers 1-10 is boring and lifeless. Its just your guild vs your alt guilds from your realm. B-A. done.

You really should realize that this is not how guild wars is played in the majority of the other servers.

[DaBooMan]

I agree with what Joker has said.


With no guild wars, the top coiners don't have a reason for their tenure in a guild to be secure.

The host and VHs will wield too much power, since the guild will have all their buffs with no need to defend them.

Alts will only multiply, moreso than they are now.


Morgan, you didn't think that part through.

The guild buffs need to be earned, defended, and possibly lost. Otherwise, there's no reason to try recruiting/maintaining the strong players to your guild anymore.


I know where you are coming from, since I also played in the earlier servers before.

Guild wars in servers 1-10 is boring and lifeless. Its just your guild vs your alt guilds from your realm. B-A. done.

You really should realize that this is not how guild wars is played in the majority of the other servers.

Server 1 actually has a realm with alot more activity than most of the server wide GW, Please have the facts to hand before you think you know best.
GW should be replaced, but with a more up to date version.
Things are getting Dated, Just waiting on the Devs i suppose.

[Morgan le Fay]

How would it create more alts than there is now? Apart from being feeders and maps there would be no other use for them. The need for them in GWs have been taken out of the equation. Unless you are prepared to coin up you alts too, it'll be a long time before they acquire the better buffs anyway. Level 5 will take some doing if it's alts only.

Servers 1-10 for the most part really don't have to work at keeping cities but do any of the hosts and VHs wield unnecessary force? No. Are any of the big players kicked so the host can feel better about their egos? No. There is some movement due to gaining more in Banish but that's squarely on the players themselves. Never once have I ever heard of a player being kicked out of a guild in any game for doing too well.

I have hosted and played in guilds and alliances in many different games. One thing I have noticed that if any host becomes a despot, that team quickly disintegrates. Ironically with the big players leading the mutiny. So trust me Hosts and VHs bullying members won't be a problem.

[BLITZBLITZWOLF_4797025]

Thanks for the thread.
What i understand is wants more rewards and fun at GW.
My idea is split GW into Guild Level start from L3 guild
L3 guild
Those L3 guild in server are right to bid 5 cities its call class 3 cities
total of 5 city are to fight between L3 guilds only.

L4 guild
They have class 4 cities which are 5 city given rep: and 3 city for additional income.(fight between L4 guilds only)

L5 guild
They have class 5 cities which are 5 city given rep: 3 city for additional income and 3 guild chest additional..(fight between L5 guilds only)

L6 guild
They have class 6 cities which are 5 city given rep: 3 city for additional income, 3 guild chest additional and 100% pirate rewards..(fight between L6 guilds only)


L7 Guild
They have class 7 cities which are 5 city given rep: 3 city for additional income, 3 guild chest additional, 100% pirate rewards and 1 free laby.(fight between L7 guilds only)


L8 Guild
They have class 7 cities which are 5 city given rep: 3 city for additional income, 3 guild chest additional, 100% pirate rewards, 1 free laby and 150 stam..(fight between L7 guilds only)


so all Level guild will benefit from GW once the Lower level guild they think strong enough to go another level,
they will upgrade and fight with another guild.
so lower level player and lower level guild will still play in the game and they will get city buff.
meanwhile those lower guild can be united and stronger, so some day they can be match for higher class city and guild.

This is just my 2 cent idea whether come true or not it’s up to tynon

Anyway
'Keep going with the suggestions!'
SO KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK
"NEVER DIE TRYING"
LET’S POST IT

[BLITZBLITZWOLF_4797025]

If there are only 1 same level guild in entire server what those players in guild going to do?

GW will having bid everyday if there is no other same level guild in server NPCS will bid (Tynon will bid)

Who are those NPCS?
NPCS 1: Player's Clone who join the GW. so you have to fight against your clone at GW
NPCS 2: multi range power of banesh boss camp A and camp F so guildies need to split team to def from losing cities.

What do you think?