I apologize, I went from Archangel V to Dominion 3, which is 3 successful sanctifications. I used multiple cards on each one to succeed. Sorry for the mistype.
In that case, there is one very good way to check if you were really successful.
Did the 3 successful sanctifications show up as world chat banners?
If they did, then you should have those in your hero, or Tynon owes you some cards.