Thank you for your reply. It's good to know that there are still people reading the forum and offering help. Queen P's behavior was totally a glitch....just as other players were experiencing their "invisible substitutes."

My advice is: Do not deviate from the example formations. Prophet E (or Herja) .. Rhize (not KT) .. Main
blank .. Adam (not Lance) .. Gen Al
blank .. blank .. blank
Sub 1:Queen P
Sub 2:Khan
Rhize was a Half Angel with one attack saint and had only 8 stars. But he hit harder than KT with 13 stars.
I tried putting Khan in where Al starts, but Tynon liked that Al died there...then Khan occupies the spot.

QP's HP was 189,000....not sure if that mattered.

Hope this helpful